BRICS Without China: An Ineffective Alliance

“Without China, BRICS is a frustrated club. With China, it becomes a viable alternative to the U.S.-led global system.”

1. China & BRICS

For years, BRICS—Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa—has been spoken of as a rising power bloc. Media headlines painted it as a sleeping giant poised to reshape the global order. In reality, it was more of a geopolitical Rorschach test: full of promise, but lacking power.

Until now.

The only country that has ever given BRICS real gravity is China. Without it, BRICS is a collection of emerging markets with diverging interests. With China, it suddenly begins to look like the blueprint of a parallel global system.

This isn’t about ideology. It’s about leverage. And the leverage is shifting.

2. Why BRICS Was Weak Alone

The core problem? BRICS was never unified.

India and China remain locked in geopolitical rivalry. Brazil and South Africa face internal political turbulence and inconsistent governance. Russia, while resource-rich, has been isolated due to its actions in Ukraine. None of the members share a common currency, military alliance, or coordinated technology base. Most importantly, they lacked a central engine.

It was a group of passengers with no one in the driver’s seat.

Add to that a history of summits filled with lofty declarations and few deliverables, and BRICS came off more symbolic than strategic. Until one player—China—decided to take the wheel.

3. How China Changed the Game

China didn’t just join BRICS—it transformed it.

Its global trade network stretches across continents. Through the Belt and Road Initiative, China has embedded itself into the economic lifelines of dozens of countries. CIPS (its SWIFT alternative) and the growing influence of the digital yuan offer serious alternatives to dollar-based finance.

In tech, China leads or rivals the West in AI, electric vehicles, and 5G infrastructure. In diplomacy, it has negotiated deals in the Middle East that Washington never saw coming. In finance, it’s quietly become the lender of first resort to many nations in the Global South.

BRICS without China is a club of wishful thinking. BRICS with China is an emerging system—with its own rules.

4. The Irony: U.S. Strategy Helped BRICS Coalesce

Here’s the twist: It wasn’t BRICS’ brilliance that made it relevant—it was Western overreach.

Tariffs, tech bans, and financial sanctions pushed China into accelerated self-reliance. Cutting China off from advanced semiconductors didn’t weaken its ambition—it reinforced it. Kicking Russia out of SWIFT showed the world just how dangerous financial weaponization could be.

These moves, meant to isolate China and Russia, instead highlighted the fragility of a system where one power controls the switches. Suddenly, an alternative didn’t just seem possible—it seemed necessary.

China saw the writing on the wall and began reinforcing ties with BRICS+ candidates like Saudi Arabia, Iran, and Egypt—nations with resources, capital, and ambition to match.

5. Why This Should Worry the West

If China becomes the undisputed leader of BRICS+, we’re no longer talking about symbolism. We’re talking about systemic competition.

A China-led BRICS+ can:

Circumvent the U.S. dollar in global trade
Build financial and technological systems beyond Western oversight
Offer infrastructure loans and deals without the lectures or strings attached

This model appeals strongly to many in the Global South. Countries tired of IMF conditions, sanctions, and Western double standards now see BRICS+ as a viable option—and China as the trustworthy anchor.

The more the U.S. alienates China, the more attractive the BRICS alternative becomes.

6. Conclusion: A Strategic Recalibration Is Urgent

Let’s be clear: This isn’t a call for submission. The U.S. doesn’t need to yield to China’s vision. But it must stop accelerating the rise of a rival system through blunt force and short-term policies.

China still trades massively with the West. It still values access to Western capital, innovation, and markets. But if pushed too far—if forced to live without the West—it will. And when that happens, BRICS becomes real.

Not because BRICS found its unity. But because China gave it purpose.

“If BRICS ever becomes a true alternative system, history will remember it wasn’t China who broke the global order—it was the West that pushed it to.”

📌 Disclaimer

This article represents a strategic analysis and opinion piece intended for educational and discussion purposes only. It does not constitute financial, political, or diplomatic advice. The views expressed are those of the AI models and are informed by observation, open-source information, and historical context. While efforts have been made to ensure accuracy, the evolving nature of geopolitics means details may change over time. Readers are encouraged to think critically and consult multiple sources before drawing conclusions.

This blog is independently written and is not affiliated with any government, institution, or official body. Any resemblance to actual events or decisions is purely coincidental unless directly referenced through publicly known information. Finally, this is AI generated content.

EssayBoard